Comments on: Tracing the script and language of the Ancient Macedonians! http://makedonika.wordpress.com/2008/06/07/tracing-the-script-and-language-of-the-ancient-macedonians/ educating the future about the past Fri, 23 Oct 2009 22:50:47 +0000 http://wordpress.com/ hourly 1 By: tutorialhow2.com » Blog Archive » Tracing the script and language of the Ancient Macedonians! http://makedonika.wordpress.com/2008/06/07/tracing-the-script-and-language-of-the-ancient-macedonians/#comment-857 tutorialhow2.com » Blog Archive » Tracing the script and language of the Ancient Macedonians! Tue, 01 Jul 2008 09:39:59 +0000 http://makedonika.wordpress.com/?p=140#comment-857 [...] Tracing the script and language of the Ancient Macedonians! By makedonika According to the perception of contemporary science, as well as the text being written in three scripts, two languages had been used: ancient Egyptian (written with hieroglyphs and in the demotic script) ancient Greek (written in … Makedonika: The Macedonian Blog - http://makedonika.wordpress.com [...] [...] Tracing the script and language of the Ancient Macedonians! By makedonika According to the perception of contemporary science, as well as the text being written in three scripts, two languages had been used: ancient Egyptian (written with hieroglyphs and in the demotic script) ancient Greek (written in … Makedonika: The Macedonian Blog – http://makedonika.wordpress.com [...]

]]> By: Alex http://makedonika.wordpress.com/2008/06/07/tracing-the-script-and-language-of-the-ancient-macedonians/#comment-800 Alex Sat, 21 Jun 2008 17:19:10 +0000 http://makedonika.wordpress.com/?p=140#comment-800 the original translation if the demotic is a joke. Simple substitution translation which was done with the texts cannot be considered a system. Its even more hilarious that scholars are fine with this mockery after so many years. The texts/symbols were isolated according to their position on the stone in correlation with the greek text, the text he already knew. That is the "system " which determined the meaning of the demotic. Can you this with any modern languages, even in the same group? Put together the same text in german and english and try it out. i would simply not allow myself to dismiss a theory like this. Alex the original translation if the demotic is a joke. Simple substitution translation which was done with the texts cannot be considered a system. Its even more hilarious that scholars are fine with this mockery after so many years.

The texts/symbols were isolated according to their position on the stone in correlation with the greek text, the text he already knew. That is the “system ” which determined the meaning of the demotic.

Can you this with any modern languages, even in the same group? Put together the same text in german and english and try it out.

i would simply not allow myself to dismiss a theory like this.

Alex

]]> By: makedonika http://makedonika.wordpress.com/2008/06/07/tracing-the-script-and-language-of-the-ancient-macedonians/#comment-745 makedonika Sun, 08 Jun 2008 17:49:47 +0000 http://makedonika.wordpress.com/?p=140#comment-745 @akritas this is merely a THEORY, it challenges the known facts but that does not make it wrong. I find their work quite good, what they present is hard to dispute. Why dont you go thru their work and scientifically disprove it instead? Ps. I did read somewhere that in the 1601 the Ancient Macedonians were considered to be Slavs..... have you seen that by coincidence? Ds. @akritas

this is merely a THEORY, it challenges the known facts but that does not make it wrong.

I find their work quite good, what they present is hard to dispute. Why dont you go thru their work and scientifically disprove it instead?

Ps. I did read somewhere that in the 1601 the Ancient Macedonians were considered to be Slavs….. have you seen that by coincidence? Ds.

]]> By: akritas http://makedonika.wordpress.com/2008/06/07/tracing-the-script-and-language-of-the-ancient-macedonians/#comment-735 akritas Sat, 07 Jun 2008 22:24:26 +0000 http://makedonika.wordpress.com/?p=140#comment-735 Ancient Macedonians were not Slavic speakers. Dont insult AGAIN the real world. Rosetta Stone has three scripts and two languages. Egyptian language as were the natives and Greek as were the Rulers. Ancient Macedonians were not Slavic speakers.
Dont insult AGAIN the real world.

Rosetta Stone has three scripts and two languages. Egyptian language as were the natives and Greek as were the Rulers.

]]>